跳到内容

Peter Jordon · Real estate insights

Term of the Week · No. 1

Market Value: Why the Numbers Don’t Always Match

By Peter Jordon, CPA, CA, AACI, P.App. | Broker

Information current: September 25, 2026

Architectural models of a house and a small commercial building on a desk, illustrating property valuation.
AI-generated editorial illustration; these models do not depict properties offered for sale.

Executive Summary

A property can have an asking price, a negotiated sale price, an MPAC assessment and an appraised market value—and those numbers may differ. Understanding what each measures helps you interpret an offer, plan a sale or prepare for financing. For our first Term of the Week, we’re looking at market value and the question to ask before relying on any property number: what does it represent, and as of which date?

Key Takeaways

  • An asking price expresses a seller’s pricing strategy; it does not establish market value.
  • A sale price is important evidence, interpreted alongside the transaction’s terms and circumstances.
  • Ontario’s 2026 property assessments continue to use a January 1, 2016 valuation date.
  • An appraisal’s effective date matters, and an appraisal alone does not guarantee mortgage approval.

What does market value mean?

In plain language, market value is the price a property would most likely command on a specified date, given reasonable market exposure and informed buyers and sellers acting without undue pressure. This paraphrases the Appraisal Institute of Canada’s definition; the precise property rights and sale terms also matter. [1]

That makes market value a useful starting point for a decision, but it does not promise a particular result. A seller still has to attract a buyer, negotiate acceptable terms and complete the transaction. A buyer still has to decide whether the property suits their needs and budget.

An appraised market value is a professional opinion supported by analysis. Its effective date tells you when that opinion applies, which may differ from the date the property was inspected or the report was written. [1] Before comparing two valuations, check their dates and assumptions. A report prepared today could, for example, address a value required for an earlier date.

Four numbers, four different questions

The distinction becomes easier to see when each number is paired with the question it answers.

A quick comparison

On smaller screens, swipe or scroll sideways to read the full table.

Number What it tells you
Asking price What is the seller asking under the current listing strategy?
Sale price What amount did the buyer and seller agree to, on the transaction’s particular terms?
MPAC assessed value What value is used for property assessment purposes? For 2026 taxation, the valuation base remains January 1, 2016.
Appraised market value What does the appraiser conclude the specified property interest would most probably sell for as of the effective date, subject to the report’s assumptions?

These are different measures, not a ranking from least to most reliable. Definitions summarized from AIC and MPAC; see sources 1–3.

An asking price can be set to invite competition, test demand or leave room for negotiation. Consequently, a sale above asking is not, by itself, proof that a buyer overpaid. Equally, a discount from asking does not automatically establish a bargain. Both comparisons use a seller-selected starting point.

A sale price deserves close attention because it records an actual agreement. MPAC explains that transaction circumstances, market exposure and relationships between the parties help determine how useful that sale is as evidence. [2] The practical question is whether the transaction reflects the market you are trying to understand.

Why the MPAC figure can look so different

For the 2026 property tax year , Ontario assessments remain based on fully phased-in January 1, 2016 values , according to MPAC. MPAC still reviews changes such as additions, new construction and changes in use, so an individual assessment can change even while the valuation base remains the same. [3]

The implication is straightforward: an assessment used for a 2026 tax bill should not be read as MPAC’s estimate of a property’s September 2026 selling price. Nor should you apply a fixed percentage to every assessment to estimate today’s value. Different properties and locations need their own evidence.

A simple example: the discount that proves very little

Imagine a property advertised at $1,100,000 . A buyer agrees to pay $1,050,000 , while its MPAC assessment is $620,000 . These figures are entirely hypothetical and do not describe a listing, appraisal or local market benchmark.

The buyer paid $50,000 below asking, but that calculation does not tell us whether the agreed price was attractive. We would still need to examine comparable transactions and the property itself. The assessment adds another number, but its different valuation date prevents a direct comparison with today’s negotiated price.

Now suppose a current appraisal concludes a different amount. The useful response is to examine the evidence, effective date, property details and transaction terms behind the difference. Selecting whichever figure best supports the result we want would leave the central question unanswered.

What changes for financing and investment property?

A lender may require a property valuation, and that value can differ from the purchase price. [4] The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada also explains that preapproval does not guarantee a mortgage: the property’s value, down payment and the lender’s requirements still affect the lending decision. [5]

For buyers, this makes the timing of the financing conversation important. If the value accepted by the lender is below the purchase price, the expected financing may be insufficient. Discuss the property and any valuation requirements with your lender or mortgage broker before assuming your preapproval covers the transaction. The appraisal informs the decision; it does not itself approve the loan.

For a rental or commercial property, the evidence may also include income and expenses. MPAC’s explanation of valuation approaches distinguishes sales comparison, income and cost methods. [6] A useful investment discussion therefore goes beyond the asking price: what income is actually supported, which expenses have been allowed for, and what assumptions depend on future events?

Consider a vacant storefront marketed on the rent it might earn once leased. That expectation needs scrutiny. A prospective lease and an executed lease are different pieces of evidence, and costs or delays in securing a tenant may affect the investment case. This is an illustrative consideration, not a valuation of a particular property.

Put the number in context before acting on it

When someone says a property is “worth” a particular amount, ask about its purpose, date and supporting evidence . Those three questions turn a headline figure into a more useful conversation.

A listing discussion can help you explore pricing and positioning. Where a formal value opinion is needed, clarify the assignment and who will rely on it. AIC identifies financing, estate planning and litigation among the circumstances in which a professional appraisal may help. [7] The right work depends on the decision you need to make.

Explore more definitions in our Glossary of Terms .

Sources

  1. Appraisal Institute of Canada — CUSPAP 2026 , effective April 1, 2026; definitions 3.26 and 3.51.
  2. MPAC — Homeowners’ Hub , discussion of sale prices and assessed values.
  3. MPAC — The Assessment Cycle , 2026 tax-year valuation base and property changes.
  4. TD — Other Costs to Consider , property valuation and purchase price.
  5. Financial Consumer Agency of Canada — Getting preapproved for a mortgage , page dated October 15, 2025.
  6. MPAC — Three Approaches to Value .
  7. Appraisal Institute of Canada — For Residential Property Owners .

Have a property value question?

Whether you are buying, selling or reviewing a residential or commercial property, Peter can help you identify the market information and professional services suited to your next decision.

Let’s Talk About Your Property Book a Meeting

General information only; this article is not a valuation of any property. Formal appraisal services are separate engagements.

Professional Real Estate Consulting Services