GTA Home Sales Fell 9%—Why Lower Prices Were Not Enough
GTA Home Sales Fell 9%—Why Lower Prices Were Not Enough
By Peter Jordon · Last updated October 6, 2026
AI-generated editorial illustration; not a photograph of a specific property or people.
Executive Summary
TRREB’s October 6 release shows GTA home sales fell 9% year over year in September despite lower prices, while Canada’s services survey recorded a fourth month of contraction. Together, these reports strengthen concern that business uncertainty and employment worries could keep households from committing to a purchase, although they do not establish that tariffs caused the sales decline. August’s larger trade surplus offers limited reassurance because shipments were accelerated ahead of new tariffs. The near-term property outlook therefore warrants more caution about transaction timing and tenant demand, with decisions grounded in local sales, actual financing terms and income resilience.
Key Takeaways
- September GTA sales totalled 5,040; the benchmark price fell 4.7% year over year and the average fell 5.1% to $1,006,409.
- New listings dropped 14.4% to 16,500, yet that smaller flow did not produce a broad price rebound.
- Canada’s services PMI improved to 48.3 from 46.8 but remained below 50, signalling slower contraction rather than a return to growth.
- August’s C$4.2-billion merchandise trade surplus was accompanied by a surge in U.S.-bound shipments; tariff-related timing complicates the outlook.
- For commercial owners, weaker service-business demand is a leasing risk to investigate, not evidence of an automatic change in rents or property values.
A cheaper market can still be a hesitant market
For a buyer who has been waiting for lower prices, September delivered them—but not the confidence to act. The Toronto Regional Real Estate Board’s September release recorded 5,040 sales, down 9% from a year earlier. That was a sharper annual decline than August’s 2.1% drop, even though both the composite benchmark and the average selling price were lower than a year ago.
TRREB attributed the pause to uncertainty about the economy, inflation and borrowing costs. That is the board’s interpretation, not a household-level survey finding. The reported market facts are narrower: sales, new listings and both price measures were lower after seasonal adjustment than in August, while September sales and prices were also lower than a year earlier.
The distinction matters. A lower price can improve the purchase equation, but it does not eliminate the risk of job loss, a payment shock at renewal or a property that needs more capital than expected. Buyers do not act on price alone; they act when price, financing and personal confidence line up.
Original chart by PeterJordon.ca using figures in the Toronto Regional Real Estate Board’s August and September 2026 market releases. Published September 3 and October 6, 2026. Figures compare each month with the same month in 2025; they are not month-over-month changes. September release · August release.
The chart shows the change in tone: September’s annual sales decline widened markedly, while the annual price declines also became larger. New listings were already contracting sharply in August and fell by a similar proportion in September. This is evidence of a market with fewer buyers and fewer new sellers—not proof that one side has suddenly taken control everywhere.
Fewer new listings did not produce a price rebound
September brought 16,500 new listings, 14.4% fewer than a year earlier. Because sales fell by a smaller percentage, the simple sales-to-new-listings ratio rose from about 28.7% in September 2025 to 30.5% in September 2026. Those ratios are derived from TRREB’s reported counts: 5,040 sales and 16,500 new listings this year, versus approximately 5,540 and 19,270 a year earlier.
That arithmetic can sound like tightening conditions, but it needs context. The ratio improved because the flow of new listings declined faster than sales; it did not improve because more homes sold. At the same time, TRREB’s benchmark and average price measures both moved lower year over year and edged lower from August after seasonal adjustment.
The practical reading is more restrained: a smaller pipeline of fresh listings may reduce choice in some neighbourhoods, but it has not yet created broad upward price pressure. Buyers and sellers should examine the active competitive set, recent comparable sales and days on market for the specific property type and location. The GTA-wide average does not tell a condo seller in downtown Toronto or a detached buyer in York Region how many credible alternatives exist nearby.
A 2.25% policy rate is helpful, not decisive
On September 2, the Bank of Canada held its policy rate at 2.25%. The Bank said the economy and inflation were evolving broadly as forecast, but it also identified greater upside risk to inflation from energy costs and tariffs. Its next scheduled decision and Monetary Policy Report are due October 28.
The policy rate directly influences variable borrowing costs and broader lender pricing, but it does not set every mortgage rate. Fixed rates also reflect bond-market conditions, funding costs, competition and borrower characteristics. Qualification depends on income, debt, down payment and the lender’s underwriting rules.
That helps explain why a lower-price environment does not automatically unlock transactions. A household may see better value and still wait for employment clarity or a more comfortable monthly payment. An investor may see a lower acquisition price and still decline if rent, condominium fees, taxes, repairs and financing leave little margin for error.
The latest available provincial labour data add useful context without predicting September sales. Statistics Canada reported Ontario’s unemployment rate at 6.9% in August, little changed from July and 0.8 percentage points below August 2025. September labour data had not been released when this article was prepared. That makes the next employment report a relevant confirmation point rather than evidence already embedded in the housing numbers.
Trade uncertainty is weighing on the service economy
The broader economic evidence gives households another reason to hesitate. On October 5, President Trump said he was “in no rush” to restart trade talks with Canada. That statement reinforces the risk of a prolonged dispute; it is not itself a new tariff measure or a reliable timetable for negotiations. For an employer deciding whether to expand, uncertainty about how long existing barriers will last can matter alongside the tariff rate.
The September services survey adds evidence that the pressure extends beyond exporters of manufactured goods. Reuters’ October 5 report on S&P Global’s survey put the Business Activity Index at 48.3, its fourth consecutive reading below the 50 no-change threshold. New business registered 48.5 and export orders weakened further. S&P Global linked the difficult conditions to tariffs, reduced export trade and uncertainty associated with the Middle East conflict. These are national survey findings, not a measurement of Ontario services output or a percentage decline in GDP.
There is a meaningful counterpoint: activity improved from August’s 46.8, the composite index rose from 47.8 to 48.7, and expectations strengthened. The survey therefore describes continuing contraction at a slower pace. Trading Economics’ account of the S&P Global results also reports lower staffing, reflecting weaker work volumes as well as difficulty recruiting suitable employees. That makes employment decisions worth watching, but does not establish a new Ontario-wide wave of layoffs.
For property decisions, the concern is the connection between uncertain business revenue, restrained hiring or investment, and households postponing a large commitment. September’s GTA resale figures are consistent with that pathway, but do not isolate its causes. The combined evidence supports a more cautious near-term view of housing activity; it does not justify assigning the entire sales decline to tariffs or forecasting a particular additional price drop.
Why the larger trade surplus offers limited reassurance
Canada’s August merchandise trade surplus widened to C$4.2 billion from a revised C$787 million in July, according to Statistics Canada’s October 6 release. Exports to the United States rose 8.1% month over month. Those are goods-trade figures for August, not an October reading of the economy or a measure of total GDP.
Reuters reported that exporters accelerated shipments ahead of new tariffs, with the U.S. share of Canadian exports returning to almost 70%. Desjardins’ October 6 analysis likewise says tariff timing may have brought shipments forward. The extent of that effect is not separately measured here. A strong month can include orders that would otherwise have shipped later, so the surplus alone is insufficient grounds to upgrade the growth outlook or assume that U.S. exposure has diminished.
September trade data will help test whether the strength persisted after those measures took effect. They will still require interpretation alongside shipment timing, prices and subsequent policy changes; one later release will not remove every distortion.
What the numbers mean for buyers
Buyers have two advantages that did not exist at the same scale in the most competitive years: lower broad price measures and a market where many sellers cannot assume multiple offers. But negotiating power is local. A well-priced home with scarce attributes can still attract competition even when the GTA total is weak.
Before treating the 5.1% decline in average price as a personal affordability gain, compare the actual property with recent sales of similar homes. Then stress-test the payment at the offered mortgage rate, not the Bank of Canada’s overnight rate, and include taxes, insurance, condominium fees, repairs and near-term capital needs. A lower purchase price is valuable only if the ownership cost remains durable.
What the numbers mean for sellers
The temptation is to focus on the 14.4% decline in new listings and assume scarcity will support price. September’s price measures argue against that shortcut. A listing can face less new competition and still miss the market if buyers are cautious or if comparable properties are priced more convincingly.
Sellers should anchor expectations to recent completed transactions, current competition and the condition of the property. If a planned sale depends on a rapid market rebound, that assumption deserves a contingency: a longer marketing period, a different pricing strategy or flexibility on timing.
What the numbers mean for residential investors
For investors, the September figures are a screening signal rather than a return forecast. A lower acquisition price can improve the going-in yield, but only if the rent is supportable, vacancy and turnover are realistic, and expenses are complete. TRREB’s resale data do not establish rental growth, condominium operating costs or financing terms.
The market’s hesitation may create negotiating opportunities, particularly where a seller values certainty. It can also make the exit assumption more fragile. Underwriting should therefore separate current evidence from the hoped-for benefit of pent-up demand. The latter may be real, but September did not show it converting into more transactions.
Commercial exposure extends beyond export manufacturers
The services survey broadens the questions commercial owners need to ask. If firms defer contracts or hiring, office tenants may postpone expansion and business-service tenants may need less space. Small-bay industrial occupiers serving those businesses could also feel weaker demand. These are potential channels from operating conditions to leasing decisions; the survey does not measure GTA office or industrial absorption, rents, capitalization rates or values.
Residential turnover adds a separate local connection. Fewer home sales can reduce work for moving, renovation, furnishing and other property-related businesses. For neighbourhood commercial and mixed-use owners, the useful evidence is whether that is affecting their tenants’ revenue and ability to renew, rather than the GTA sales percentage alone.
This supports a modestly more cautious view of tenant demand, especially where a near-term lease expiry coincides with concentrated customer or U.S. revenue exposure. Review the tenant’s cash position and order book, the cost of securing a replacement occupier, and how readily the premises can accommodate another use. A flexible industrial building serving several industries has different risks from a specialized export facility; neither should be valued by applying a mechanical adjustment to a national PMI reading.
What would improve the outlook?
Lower prices can improve affordability, and September’s slower pace of services contraction is a reason to avoid treating every indicator as worsening. Even so, GTA sales weakened while trade uncertainty persisted. The stronger case for caution is about the timing of purchases and leasing commitments; it is not a quantified forecast for property prices or a new financing-risk rating.
The next useful evidence will be September employment and trade data, the Bank of Canada’s October 28 decision and Monetary Policy Report, and October’s local sales and listing patterns. A more constructive outlook would need firmer evidence that businesses are sustaining orders and employment and that households are converting interest into completed transactions. In the meantime, decisions should remain workable if a sale takes longer, a tenant postpones expansion or financing terms fail to improve.
Sources
- TRREB: Economic Uncertainty Kept GTA Homebuyers on the Sidelines in September, published October 6, 2026. Primary source for September sales, listings, price measures and seasonally adjusted direction.
- TRREB: August 2026 market release, published September 3, 2026. Primary source for the August comparison used in the original chart.
- Bank of Canada: policy-rate decision, September 2, 2026. Primary source for the 2.25% policy rate, inflation risks and the October 28 decision date.
- Statistics Canada: Labour Force Survey, August 2026, published September 4, 2026. Primary source for Ontario’s August unemployment rate.
- Reuters: Trump’s comments on Canadian trade talks, October 5, 2026 remarks; Reuters Connect item indexed October 6.
- Reuters: September Canada services PMI, via Investing.com, published October 5, 2026; reporting on S&P Global’s national survey.
- Trading Economics: Canada services PMI, October 5, 2026 survey account; underlying provider S&P Global.
- Statistics Canada: Canadian international merchandise trade, August 2026, published October 6, 2026.
- Reuters: Canada’s August merchandise trade surplus, published October 6, 2026; shipment-timing explanation.
- Desjardins: Canada trade surplus and new U.S. tariffs, published October 6, 2026; economist interpretation of shipment timing.
What does the September market mean for your decision?
Broad statistics are useful only when they are connected to the right neighbourhood, property type, financing and timing. Let’s discuss the evidence relevant to your residential or commercial real estate decision.
Peter Jordon
CPA, CA, AACI, P.App. | Broker
General market commentary, not property-specific financial, legal, mortgage or investment advice. Formal appraisal services are separate engagements.